Winter Habits: What to Keep and What to Let Go

Some links below go to Amazon. If you buy through one, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — it does not change what I recommend or what anything costs.

Why Winter Breaks Habits

There are real, physical reasons, and knowing them removes the moral dimension that makes the whole thing worse.

Light exposure drops sharply, and light is the primary input to your circadian system. The consequence is later melatonin, worse sleep quality, and lower daytime alertness, none of which are attitude problems.

Energy availability drops. A substantial number of people experience a seasonal shift in mood and energy, ranging from mild to clinically significant. Planning as though your October capacity is your January capacity is planning against known facts.

And the environment stops cooperating. Habits that depend on being outdoors, on daylight, or on other people being available all lose their supporting conditions at once.

The Audit: Three Columns

Take your current habits and sort them.

Keep unchanged. Habits that are indifferent to season. Anything indoors, short, and not dependent on daylight or motivation. These are your foundation and they should be the majority of what you carry into winter.

Adapt. Habits worth keeping in modified form. The hour walk becomes twenty minutes at lunch, when there is actually light. The gym at six becomes the gym at noon. Adaptation is not failure and it is not a reduced version of yourself, it is the thing that keeps the habit alive until March.

Retire until spring. Deliberately. This is the column people refuse to use, and refusing it is what causes the collapse. A habit you consciously suspend with a restart date is paused. A habit you keep failing at is a running source of self-criticism that eventually takes the other habits down with it.

Write the restart date for each retired habit. Late March is usually about right.

What to Add for Winter Specifically

Winter has its own requirements, and a good winter habit set includes things that are unnecessary in June.

• Light in the morning. Getting outside within an hour of waking, even under cloud, or using a light box if that is not possible. This is the single highest-leverage winter habit and it affects sleep, mood, and energy together.
• A fixed wake time. More important than bedtime, and more important in winter than at any other point in the year, because the usual cues are gone.
• Something that gets you out of the house. Anything. The threshold for not leaving is very low in winter and the cost compounds quickly.
• One social commitment with an obligation attached. Not an intention to see people. Something fixed, involving someone who would notice your absence.
• Movement that requires no decision. The same thing, at the same time, indoors, that you do not have to be in the mood for.

A habit you can see on a page survives a bad month far better than one you are tracking in your head. The Undated Habit Tracker is undated, so you can start it in November without wasting eleven months of empty boxes.

Lower the Bar and Keep the Schedule

The key principle for winter tracking is that frequency matters more than intensity.

A habit performed at twenty percent every scheduled day stays alive. A habit performed at full intensity twice and then abandoned is gone. Since your capacity is genuinely lower, the only way to protect the schedule is to lower the target.

So define a minimum version for each habit, explicitly, in writing. Not the aspiration. The floor. Five minutes. One page. Around the block. The floor is what you do on the day you are flattened, and the existence of a defined floor is what stops a bad day becoming a bad month.

Mark the floor days differently in your tracker if you like, but mark them as done. They are done.

Track It Where You Can See It

Winter is when visual tracking earns its keep, because internal motivation is not available to be relied on.

The reason a physical chart outperforms memory is that winter distorts self-assessment. In February you will be certain you have done nothing for weeks, and a page showing eleven marks in the last fourteen days is the only thing that will correct you. That correction is not cosmetic. Believing you have collapsed is usually what causes the collapse.

Keep it somewhere unavoidable and keep it simple. A mark or no mark. Elaborate systems do not survive low-energy seasons, which is precisely when you need them.

The Permission Part

There is a version of winter habit advice that amounts to fighting harder against your own physiology, and it produces a lot of exhausted people in March.

Some reduction is correct. Most of human history was organized around doing less in the dark half of the year, and the expectation of identical output in every month is recent and not obviously wise.

So build the smaller set, protect the schedule, and take the retired column seriously. Coming out of winter with your core habits intact and having deliberately paused four things is a good outcome. Coming out of it having abandoned everything in November and felt bad about it since is the common one.

Further reading

Two books that actually change what you do, rather than how you feel about it:

• Atomic Habits — James Clear. The standard text on making a habit small enough to survive a bad month.
• Tiny Habits — BJ Fogg. Better than Clear on the specific problem of starting when your energy is low.